Pencil Mustache: 4 Different Styles & How to Shave Each

The pencil mustache—a thin line of facial hair that has graced the upper lips of icons like Clark Gable, Little Richard, and even Brad Pitt. This mustache style is all about precision, definition, and a touch of old-school charm.

Some go for the classic Vincent Price Hollywood ‘stache, while others prefer a modern, edgy vibe. No matter the aesthetic, mastering the perfect pencil mustache takes the right tools, technique, and patience.

In this guide, we’ll explore the different pencil mustache styles and how to shave and maintain each one. If you’ve been thinking about rocking this timeless style, you’re in the right place.

What Is a Pencil Mustache?

The pencil mustache has been a staple of refined style for over a century. Barbers and facial hair specialists often recommend it for men who want a low-maintenance yet highly intentional mustache style. Its precise lines and defined look make it a favorite among men who prefer a clean but distinctive aesthetic.

A pencil mustache is a thin, precisely shaped mustache that sits just above the upper lip. Unlike fuller, bushier mustaches, this one focuses on clean lines, sharp definition, and minimalism. It’s called a pencil mustache because, well, it looks like it was drawn on with a fine-tip pencil.

The pencil thin mustache style has had its highs and lows in popularity, but it never disappears and is effortlessly cool when done right.

Who Should Try a Pencil Mustache?

• Anyone who likes a clean-cut, defined look.

• Men who can’t grow thick facial hair but still want a stylish mustache.

• Those looking for a vintage, classic appeal or a bold, artistic aesthetic.

• For people with oval or angular face shapes, this style helps highlight cheekbones and jawlines.

4 Types of Pencil Mustache Styles

Not all pencil mustaches are created equal. While they share the same thin, defined appearance, there are subtle variations that change the overall vibe. Let’s break down the most popular pencil facial hair styles:

1. The Classic Pencil Mustache

This is the OG of pencil mustaches. It’s a thin, neatly trimmed, straight line mustache that barely extends past the corners of the mouth. It’s a style that whispers, “refined gentleman” rather than shouts it. Think David Niven, or any old-school leading man.

• Start by trimming your mustache down to a fine line using a T-blade trimmer.

• Use a razor or precision trimmer to create clean edges just below your mustache hairline and above the lip.

• Apply a small dab of mustache wax to keep it sleek and in place.

2. The Parted Pencil Mustache

A variation of the classic style, this mustache has a small gap in the middle right under the philtrum (the groove between your nose and upper lip). The break in the center creates a stylish, intentional look that feels both vintage and artistic, like the classic actor Errol Flynn.

• Follow the classic pencil mustache steps, but carefully shave a thin gap in the center to create the parted style.

• Use a razor for precision. Note that this style requires steady hands!

• Apply a little beard cream to keep the hair soft and easy to shape.

3. Parted Pencil Mustache with Goatee

For those who want a little more facial hair while still keeping things refined, the parted pencil mustache with a goatee is a perfect balance. The thin, defined mustache pairs well with a neatly trimmed goatee, adding structure to the face and creating a sharp look.

• Starting with the goatee, trim it into a well-defined shape, keeping the edges crisp using a T-blade trimmer or razor.

• Shape the mustache into a parted pencil style, ensuring a small gap in the center.

• Keep the cheeks clean-shaven to enhance the contrast between the mustache and goatee.

• Use mustache wax to keep the mustache in place and beard oil to keep the goatee soft and manageable.

4. The Curved Pencil Mustache

A slight curve at the ends of the mustache adds personality to this style. It leans into a relaxed, vintage aesthetic reminiscent of 1930s film stars and jazz musicians.

• Trim your mustache into a thin line, following the natural curve of your upper lip.

• Gently taper the ends using a trimmer or beard scissors.

• Apply a bit of beard oil for moisture and then style with mustache wax for a polished hold. 

How to Maintain a Pencil Mustache

Men's grooming professionals agree that a well-maintained mustache can transform your overall appearance. Celebrity stylists and barbers emphasize the importance of regular upkeep to keep your pencil mustache looking sharp rather than unkempt. A neglected mustache can quickly lose its signature precision, so following a solid grooming routine is key.

Once you’ve nailed the shape, keeping it looking sharp is key. Here’s how to maintain your pencil mustache like a pro:

1. Trim Regularly

The pencil mustache isn’t a “set it and forget it” style. It requires frequent upkeep to keep it looking fresh. Trim every few days, or as needed, with a T-blade trimmer or beard scissors.

2. Keep It Conditioned

A dry, wiry mustache is not a good look. Apply beard oil daily to soften the hair and keep it looking neat. Regularly wash your facial hair with nourishing beard and face wash.

3. Shape It with Mustache Wax

A tiny amount of mustache wax will help define the shape and keep stray hairs in check.

4. Clean Up the Edges

Use a razor or beard trimmer to keep the surrounding areas clean-shaven, emphasizing the contrast between the mustache and the rest of your face.

5. Stay Patient

Perfecting a pencil mustache takes practice. If your first attempt isn’t flawless, don’t worry—you’ll get better with time. Most mustache styles, like the handlebar mustache, take time and training. If you need a little boost, explore The Beard Club’s oils, creams, and more designed to support healthy facial hair growth.

Should You Try a Pencil Mustache?

A pencil mustache isn’t just a look. It’s a statement. If you’re considering it, think about your face shape, hair growth pattern, and personal style. Barbers often recommend this style for oval and angular face shapes since it sharpens features and adds a touch of vintage sophistication. But let’s be honest—if you’ve got the confidence to pull it off, that’s half the battle won.

The pencil mustache perfectly fits those who appreciate precision and minimalism. It’s sharp, refined, and surprisingly versatile. The trick is keeping it well-groomed—a pencil mustache that's too undefined quickly loses its charm.

Need the right tools? Check out The Beard Club’s beard care products to keep your mustache in top form! With the right technique and care, you’ll be rocking a pencil mustache that’s equal parts suave and stylish. Confidence is the secret ingredient to pulling off any facial hair or beard style.

Happy trimming!

Sources:

Pencil Moustache: The Debonair Dozen | Norton of Morton

Ode to A Pencil Thin Mustache | In So Many Words